Keywords: Breathing thermal manikin, airborne transmission, cross-infection, indoor air quality, human exposure

Peter V Nielsen
Chen Zhang
Wenhui Yuan
Department of the Built Environment, Aalborg University, Denmark
pvn@civil.aau.dk
Department of the Built Environment, Aalborg University, Denmark
Department of the Built Environment, Aalborg University, Denmark

 

Using a thermal manikin in research has a long history. The development of thermal manikins began in the 1940s, with the first prototype created by the U.S. Army in 1941 [1]. This model was made of copper and featured a simple whole-body design with a single thermal zone, which was utilized to assess the thermal insulation performance of military clothing. Since the 1960s, interest in thermal manikins has grown steadily. The first Danish thermal manikin was developed in 1967 [2]. As a test model of the human body, it enabled the assessment of thermal comfort by measuring both whole-body and local heat exchange under different environmental conditions. Thermal manikins soon became valuable tools for the development and evaluation of products such as sleeping bags, workwear, sportswear, and military uniforms.

A manikin containing a breathing function was formulated at Aalborg University in 1992. This innovation makes it possible to investigate the complex airflow patterns generated by human respiration, thermal boundary layer, as well as their interaction with room airflow, such as ventilation systems, natural ventilation, heat sources, and cold surfaces. It was installed with mouth and nose openings connected to an artificial lung that simulated human breathing. The manikin was called Comfortina, reflecting its original purpose of supporting research into thermal comfort.

The breathing function significantly expanded the capabilities of thermal manikins. It enabled the measurement of human exposure to airborne pollutants under realistic indoor conditions, including environments with temperature stratification and non-uniform contaminant concentrations. The first experimental results demonstrating these capabilities were published in 1994 [3], and since then, breathing thermal manikins have been widely used to investigate passive smoking, airborne disease transmission, ventilation performance, and human exposure to indoor pollutants.

Exposure to passive smoking

Before indoor smoking in common areas was restricted in Denmark in 2007, there was great interest in reducing the consequences of passive smoking through ventilation. By using two manikins, one representing a smoker and the other a non-smoker, it was able to study the dispersion of smoke and quantify personal exposure. The experiments demonstrated that exposure increased significantly when occupants were in close proximity, particularly in poorly ventilated spaces. The results obtained from this experiment were important steps towards understanding epidemics such as SARS and COVID-19 [4].

Figure 1. Comfortina and an AAU manikin in the study of passive smoking and airborne transmission [4].

Cross-infection risk between people standing at a short distance

The outbreak of the SARS pandemic in 2002 highlighted the need to better understand airborne transmission between occupants. Breathing thermal manikins subsequently became a valuable experimental tool. Their importance became even more evident during the COVID-19 pandemic, when they were extensively used to study short-range airborne transmission.

At the beginning of the pandemic, COVID-19 was widely believed to spread primarily through large respiratory droplets and contaminated surfaces. However, evidence from several outbreak investigations suggested that airborne transmission also played a significant role. Breathing thermal manikins provided a unique means of visualizing and quantifying the transport of exhaled aerosols under realistic indoor airflow conditions, thereby contributing to a better understanding of infection mechanisms.

As illustrated in Figure 2, the concentration of virus-laden aerosols is highest closest to an infected person and decreases rapidly with increasing distance as the aerosols are diluted by the room air. The figure also illustrates that increased ventilation will lower aerosol concentration at long distances.

Figure 2. Virus-laden aerosol dispersion in short range and long range.

Parameters that influence the cross-infection risk between people situated close to each other in a ventilated room can be summarized as distance, orientations, heights, positions, movements and number of people etc. [5]. Geometry of mouth and nose, respiratory activities, e.g. speaking, coughing and sneezing, as well as activity level of people and face masks are also important parameters influencing the cross-infection risk [5].

Surroundings variable as local air temperature, temperature gradients, air velocity and turbulence level can be studied by manikins with breathing function [5]. This helps to provide a better understanding of the infection dynamics and supports the recognition that airborne transmission is a dominant pathway for the COVID-19 pandemic [6].

In the debate about face masks, the manikin also had a role. In addition to filtering droplets and aerosols, masks alter the direction and momentum of the exhaled airflow. Rather than producing a concentrated breathing jet directly towards another person, the exhaled air is redirected and dispersed, thereby reducing short-range exposure even before particle filtration is considered [7].

Tracer gas or smoke are usually used to simulate fine airborne particles such as aerosols, viruses or bacteria. Breathing thermal manikin can also be used to investigate the transport of large droplets, as droplet infection. For example, calibrated dust, popularly called ‘Arizona Road Dust’, which has sizes between 10 and 30 μm, has been used to study droplet transport. These experiments have shown that particles of size 30 μm may remain airborne for extended periods indoors, as they are mixed into motion by the flow provided by ventilation and heat release in the room [5].

Humans are potentially exposed to microplastics through food, drink, and air. The first two pathways have received considerable scientific attention, while inhalation exposure remains much less understood. Most recently, breathing thermal manikins have been used to address human exposure to indoor airborne microplastics of different size in a realistic indoor condition [8].

Room ventilation systems and their influence on airborne infection

Breathing thermal manikin has become an important tool for evaluation the influence of ventilation systems on airborne infection risk. Figure 3compares the performance of different air distribution strategies for two occupants standing either in short distance or at a long distance. The results demonstrate that the interaction between the airflow generated by the occupants and the room ventilation has a significant influence on personal exposure, particularly within the near field (less than 1 m between occupants).

s shown in Figure 3, mixing ventilation generally provides the lowest cross-infection risk in the near zone, while displacement ventilation can in some cases, but not all, create a low impact at large distances. The cross-infection risk in Figure 3 is expressed as the ratio between inhaled concentration of the opposite person and concentration in the return flow from the room [5].

Figure 3. Typical exposures between two people of the same height standing at rest facing each other. The measurements were made in a room installed with different air distribution systems. This shows the result of the combined influence of both people and the chosen ventilation system. The vertical axes show the cross-infection risk between the two people.

Further work

Recent developments have further expanded the capabilities of breathing thermal manikins. As shown in Figure 4, moving manikins make it possible to investigate how walking and other occupant movements influence airflow patterns, contaminant transport, and personal exposure. Figure 5 illustrates a manikin with anatomically realistic internal airways, enabling more detailed studies of aerosol transport, deposition, and inhalation within the respiratory tract.

 

Two mannequins sitting in chairs

Description automatically generated

Figure 4. ‘Moving’ manikin mounted on a cart [9].

Figure 5. Mannequin with internal airways.

As buildings increasingly focus on health, resilience, and energy efficiency, breathing thermal manikins will remain an essential experimental tool in research on indoor environmental quality, ventilation, and airborne transmission.

However, there is still considerable scope for further development. Most existing studies have employed identical manikins with simplified facial geometry and breathing characteristics, whereas real occupants differ considerably in height, body shape, breathing patterns, and respiratory activities. Future breathing thermal manikins should therefore incorporate more realistic anatomical features, including detailed mouth and nose geometries, variable breathing rates, and different respiratory activities such as speaking, coughing, and sneezing. In addition, improved simulation of occupant movement and interactions between multiple occupants will enable more realistic investigations of short-range airborne transmission.

Acknowledgement

This project was financially supported by the Independent Research Fund Denmark under the REACT project (No. 3105–00106B).

Literature

[1]     I. Holmér, Thermal manikin history and applications, Eur. J. Appl. Physiol. 92 (2004) 614–618. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00421-004-1135-0.

[2]     Korsgaard, V., & Madsen, T. L. (1967). En mannequin til bestemmelse af indendørsklimaets termiske virkninger på mennesket (in Danish). VVS, (9), 407-412.

[3]     CE Hyldgaard, Humans as a Source of Heat and Air Pollution, Roomvent ’94, June 15-17, 1994, Cracow, Poland.

[4]     E Bjørn & PV Nielsen, Exposure due to Interacting Air Flows Between two Persons, Roomvent ’96, Yokohama, Japan, July 17-19, 1996.

[5]     Nielsen, PV & Xu, C 2021, ‘Multiple airflow patterns in human microenvironment and the influence on short-distance airborne cross-infection – A review’, Indoor and Built Environment. https://doi.org/10.1177/1420326X211048539

[6]     Morawska, L., Allen, J., Bahnfleth, W., Bluyssen, P. M., Boerstra, A., Buonanno, G., Cao, J., Dancer, S. J., Floto, A., Franchimon, F., Greenhalgh, T., Haworth, C., Hogeling, J., Isaxon, C., Jimenez, J. L., Kurnitski, J., Li, Y., Loomans, M., Marks, G., ... Yao, M. (2021). A paradigm shift to combat indoor respiratory infection. Science,372(6543), 689-691. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.abg2025

[7]     C Zhang, PV Nielsen, L Liu, ET Sigmer, S Mikkelsen & RL Jensen, The source control effect of personal protection equipment and physical barrier on short-range airborne transmission, Building and Environment Volume 211, 1 March 2022, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.buildenv.2022.108751

[8]     Vianello A, R L Jensen, L Liu & J Vollertsen 2019, Simulating human exposure to indoor airborne microplastics using a Breathing Thermal Manikin, Scientific Reports, https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-45054-w

[9]     Bjørn, E & Nielsen, PV, 2002, Dispersal of Exhaled Air and Personal Exposure in Displacement Ventilated Rooms, Indoor Air Online, vol. 12, no. 3, pp. 147-164. https://doi.org/10.1034/j.1600-0668.2002.08126.x

Peter V Nielsen, Chen Zhang, Wenhui YuanPages 58 - 61

Stay Informed

Follow us on social media accounts to stay up to date with REHVA actualities

0

0 product in cart.products in cart.