Alumni, RWTH Aachen
University,Chair of Construction Business and Building Services
Marten F. Brunk
Head of chair, RWTH Aachen University, Chair of Construction Business and Building Services Aachen, Germany
Key words: waste water, sewage water, heat recovery, domestic hot water, DHW, tap water, water use, heat recovery
A measurement-based analysis of the energetic potential of waste water within six buildings in Germany shows the high temperature level of the so far widely unused resource waste water. The waste water has an average temperature of about 21 to 26°C. Due to measurements of the consumption of drinking water the estimated amount of waste water for a weekday is in average 113 to 133 litres per day and person in residential buildings, 184 litres per day and room in hotels and 327 litres per day and bed in hospitals. The usage of thermal energy from waste water provided by heat pumps leads to high seasonal performance factors enabling economical as well as ecological use of the in-house heat recovery systems. To ensure the efficiency of the system the biofilm that grows on the sewage-sided heat exchanger, as a result of the nutritional richness of the waste water, has to be removed regularly.
About 5% of the total delivered energy consumption in Germany is used for water heating . Referring to buildings, the percentage of the delivered energy consumption for domestic hot water is about 11% . Due to continuous efforts to reduce the heating demand of buildings the percentage of energy used for hot water supply will increase decisively during the upcoming years. This tremendous amount of energy in the waste water is usually discharged unused in the sewage system. In order to achieve the European objectives of climate protection waste water heat recovery provides an enormous and for the most part unexploited potential to develop resource-efficient heating devices in buildings.
The idea of heat recovery from waste water
with heat pumps is certainly not new. Since the 1980s centralized systems in
In contrast to this technology, the aim of the project supported by the German Federal Ministry of Transport, Building and Urban Development called “In-house heat recovery of domestic waste water to increase the energy efficiency of buildings”, which is compiled by the Chair of Construction Business and Building Services of RWTH Aachen University, is different . Here the main objective is the decentralized use of thermal energy of all waste water flows before having entered the sewage systems within buildings to prevent the emission of energy to the surrounding soil. That’s how to explain the waste water temperatures of about 23 to 26°C on average, which are substantially higher compared to the temperatures in centralized systems. As a consequence, the efficiency and cost-effectiveness of the heat pump systems can be increased decisively. Thus, a heat cycle is built up, in which the thermal energy of the waste water can be used by means of a heat pump to produce domestic hot water directly within the building.
In the context of the research project metrological potential analysis of the energy source waste water within buildings, as well as the simulative investigation of different system concepts, is conducted in order to evaluate the efficiency of the system compared to conventional energy generation.
Figure 1. Concepts of waste water heat recovery.
In order to determine the energetic potential of waste water flows the consumption of cold drinking water, as well as the temperature of the waste water, has to be measured in the monitored objects. Here, the consumed amount of drinking water is equal to the estimator for the amount of waste water. The waste water temperature is measured redundantly with respectively two temperature sensors on each sewer. The measuring points are situated on the main sewers on the back of all internal sewers and before the waste water flow enters the sewage system (Figure 2).
Figure 2. Monitoring concept.
The six monitored objects include a multiple-family house with 19 residents in the city of Düren, another multiple-family house with 49 inhabitants in the city of Pforzheim, two student residences with 244 and 208 occupants, a business hotel with 150 rooms and a hospital with 348 beds in the city of Aachen.
Figure 3 and 4 show the representative daily variations of the consumption of drinking water and the waste water temperatures for a weekday based on arithmetic averages for one of the multiple-family houses and one of the student residences.
Figure 3. Multiple family house with 19 residents, hydrograph for a weekday.
Derived from the measurement data for the multiple family house in the city of Düren with 8 accommodation units and 19 residents from May 2012 to July 2012 the average flow on weekdays results in 117.0 litres per day and person or rather 2.2 cubic metres per day. The average waste water temperature is 22.5°C while the average temperature of cold drinking water is 14.8°C during this period. Figure 3 shows the daily fluctuation of water flow and waste water temperature. It can be noticed that the consumption of drinking water starts at 4:00 am and reaches its maximum of 8.8 litres per hour and person between 7:00 am and 8:00 am. Afterwards during the day, the flow is on a constant level between 5.6 (2:00 pm to 3:00 pm) and 6.8 (1:00 pm to 2:00 pm) litres per hour and person. During the night hours the flow increases slightly until 9:00 pm whereupon a steady decrease follows. The waste water temperature reaches its maximum average hourly value of 24.3°C (7:00 am to 8:00 am) and 25.3°C (8:00 pm to 9:00 pm) during the morning and the evening peak. The profiles of the curves are different on Saturdays and Sundays (not to be seen in the chart). The early consumption peaks begin with a three-hour delay on both days of the weekend. It is remarkable that the average consumption is with 133.9 litres per day and person higher on Sundays.
Figure 4. Student residence (TKH) with 244 residents, hydrograph for a weekday during the lecture period.
The results derived from the measurement data for the student residence in the “Theodore von Kármán” building (TKH) with 244 residents from May 2011 to February 2012 are the following: on a characteristic weekday (Monday to Friday) during the lecture period the average consumption of drinking water is 116.9 litres per day and person respectively 28.53 m³ per day while the average waste water temperature is 24.9°C. The average temperature of cold drinking water is around 11.8°C during the measurement period. Figure 4 shows the representative daily variations of the water flow and the waste water temperature. It is obvious that the drinking water consumption starts at 6:00 am in the morning and reaches its daily maximum of about 9 litres per hour and person between 8:00 am and 10:00 am. During the afternoon hours between 4:00 pm and 5:00 pm the consumption is slightly lower. Between 10:00 pm and 11:00 pm there is a second consumption peak with 6.5 litres per hour and person. The curve of the waste water temperatures shows a similar trend: The maximum hourly value of 27.2°C can be observed during the early consumption peak between 9:00 am and 10:00 am while the temperature falls to 19.9°C between 5:00 am and 6:00 am. The shape of the curve shows that during periods with much flow water the waste water temperature is higher than in periods with less flow water. On Saturdays and Sundays the profiles are slightly different (not to be seen in the chart): The consumption peaks in the morning begin with a one-hour delay on Saturdays and with a two-hour delay on Sundays.
Evaluation of the performance
Due to the high temperature level of waste water it can be described as an ideal heat source for a heat pump system, as shown in Figure 5. The waste water storage compensates the fluctuating amount of incoming waste water in the course of a day and serves at the same time as an installation site for the sewage-sided heat exchanger, which absorbs heat from the waste water. The heat pump supplies the required rise in temperature and distributes the heat on a higher temperature level to the domestic water heating. In bivalent designed systems the heat pump accomplishes a preheating of the drinking water, whereupon a second generator (a conventional gas boiler for instance) rises the temperature from the preheating-level to the drinking water temperature of 60°C. This is done in order to keep Legionella bacteria from growing and to ensure a hygienically unobjectionable supply system.
Figure 5. Possibility for using waste water energy to heat up drinking water by means of a heat pump.
In the context of the research project  different system concepts are analysed concerning their ecological and economic advantages by simulation calculations, where the hydrographs of the waste water energy profiles serve as input quantities for the simulation. In the following the simulation results are presented for a heat pump system wherein the heat pump provides a preheating of the domestic hot water to a 45°C-level and a gas boiler rises the temperature up to 60°C using the example of the student residence TKH with 244 occupants. Further constraints are:
ensuring the domestic hot water temperature JDHW = 60°C
preheating of domestic hot water through heat pumpJpre = 45°C
domestic cold water temperatureJDCW = 10°C
volume of water heaterVwater heater = 5 m³
of waste water storage Vwaste
water storage =
output of heat pump is 24 kW
· thermal disinfection of water heater once daily using the gas boiler
Because of the
nutritional richness of the medium waste water the formation of biofilms on all
contact surfaces is expected. Here, the biofilm formation on the sewage-sided
heat exchanger is of particular interest because the biofilm has a low thermal
conductivity and thus has an insulating effect and can significantly impede the
heat transfer of the heat exchanger. In the simulation a biofilm with an
average thickness of 1 mm is applied, which requires regular cleaning of the
sewage-sided heat exchanger in one-day-intervals:
of biofilm on sewage-sided heat exchanger dbio = 1 mm
conductivity of biofilm lbio = 0.5 W/m∙K
For the simulated system, a delivered energy demand for domestic hot water of 991.2 kWh/a∙person is calculated, from that the heat pump provides 475.5 kWh/a∙person and the gas boiler 515.5 kWh/a∙person. The performance factor of the heat pump is extrapolated on company data to 5.5 with a heating coverage of 48.0%. On average, the heat pump operates with a temperature rise from 17.7°C to 44°C. Based on the calculations, the waste water is cooled down to 18°C on average. Thus, no damaging effects on downstream waste water cleaning processes in the sewage treatment plant have to be expected. For detailed results, reference is made to other publications that were compiled within this research project, see .
The reduce of biofilm formation on the sewage-sided heat exchanger, for example with the help of highly innovative and automated cleaning methods, is essential for the efficiency of the system. The main objective of the research project is the expansive use of waste water as a heat source. The in-house waste water heat recovery can be considered as a forward-looking technology that can increase the energy and resource efficiency of heating devices in buildings.
 AG Energiebilanzen e.V. (ed.) (2011): Anwendungsbilanzen
für die Endenergiesektoren in Deutschland im Jahr 2008, Berlin, p. 23.
 Bundesministerium für Verkehr, Bau und
Stadtentwicklung (ed.) (2007): CO2-Gebäudereport 2007, Berlin, p. 17.
 Deutsche Vereinigung für Wasserwirtschaft,
Abwasser und Abfall e.V. (ed.) (2009): DWA-Regelwerk, Merkblatt DWA-M 114,
Energie aus Abwasser - Wärme- und Lageenergie, Hennef.
 Müller, E. A., Schmid, F. (2005): Heizen
und Kühlen mit Abwasser - Ratgeber für Bauherrschaften und Gemeinden,
Bundesamt für Energie Schweiz (ed.), Bern.
 Brunk, M.F., Seybold, C. et al. (2012): Dezentrale Wärmerückgewinnung
aus häuslichem Abwasser, Endbericht der RWTH Aachen, Lehrstuhl für Baubetrieb
und Gebäudetechnik im Forschungsprogramm Forschungsinitiative Zukunft Bau des
Bundesministeriums für Verkehr, Bau und Stadtentwicklung, Aktenzeichen
SF-10.08.18.7-10.4 also published as Brunk, M.F., Seybold, C. et al. (2013):
Dezentrale Wärmerückgewinnung aus häuslichem Abwasser, Bauforschung für die
Praxis, Bd. 105, Fraunhofer IRB Verlag, Stuttgart, ISBN 978-3-8167-9012-9.
 Forschungsvorhaben „Dezentrale
Abwasserwärmerückgewinnung zur Steigerung der Energieeffizienz von Gebäuden“
im Forschungsprogramm Forschungsinitiative Zukunft Bau des Bundesministeriums
für Verkehr, Bau und Stadtentwicklung, Aktenzeichen SF-10.08.18.7-11.38,
Projektleitung Lehrstuhl für Baubetrieb und Gebäudetechnik, Laufzeit 12/2011
– 05/2013, no preliminary reports presently published, final report expected